What Progressives Really Want, Judged by the European Fires: Destruction!

 Lionel Shriver's New Criterion lecture asks a blunt question: what do progressives actually want? Not the slogans, not the platform planks, but the deeper appetite. Her answer is uncomfortable and, in light of the 2026 European riots, difficult to dismiss. They want, above all, to remain against. A finished utopia would leave them unemployed. Real power that forces them to live with the consequences of their ideas is a threat. The recent destruction across France, Italy, Spain, Germany and elsewhere supplies a live illustration.

Shriver's core claim is that the progressive mind is more at home in permanent opposition than in construction. It thrives on the existence of evils to denounce, racism, inequality, the climate, "systemic" whatever. When the measurable evils recede, new and subtler ones are invented (microaggressions, invisible structures) so the denunciation can continue. Virtue is performed for an audience rather than pursued privately. The pandemic, she notes, offered an exhilarating chance to impose petty rules simply because one could. Once in office, the same people become less happy; the arithmetic of governing exposes the gap between what "should" work and what does. Conservatives, by contrast, more often want to be seen as right, as having produced results that survive contact with reality.

Look at the European riots. Legitimate grievances, housing costs, stagnant wages, overstretched public services, brought large peaceful crowds into the streets. That is ordinary democratic politics. What followed in city after city was not ordinary. In France, a nineteenth-century town hall in Limoges was deliberately set ablaze; shops were looted; police were attacked; thousands were arrested. Interior ministers and mayors pointed to ultra-Left groups that either instigated or refused to condemn the violence. In Milan, masked rioters turned a cost-of-living march into stone-throwing, fires and looting. Similar patterns appeared in parts of Germany, Spain and elsewhere. Social-media channels openly celebrated the loss of police control or refused to draw any line between protest and arson. Opportunistic looting by suburban gangs occurred, but the ideological permission structure, the refusal to condemn, the framing of every burned building as resistance, came from the radical Left.

This is not a bug in the progressive temperament; it is a feature of the mindset Shriver describes. Burning a town hall or a tourist office does not lower rents or raise wages. It does, however, keep the narrative of systemic failure alive. It supplies fresh footage of "resistance." It allows activists to stay in the role of the pure opposition rather than the accountable governors. When authorities respond with curfews or stricter laws, the same actors can denounce "authoritarianism," completing the loop. A society that actually solved its housing and cost-of-living problems would deprive them of the permanent campaign. Better, from that vantage, that the problems persist and the streets burn.

Shriver is careful not to claim every progressive personally desires chaos. The point is structural and psychological. The movement as a whole is most coherent when it is denouncing, inventing new categories of offense, and resisting the moment when its prescriptions must be tested. European cities in 2026 offered a clear test: the destructive fringe was not an alien intrusion but a predictable extension of a politics that treats failure as proof of righteousness and success as the loss of purpose. The fires did not advance a workable program. They advanced the permanent posture of opposition. That, more than any manifesto, is what the pattern reveals.

https://newcriterion.com/article/what-do-progressives-really-want/