The Lunatic Lunar Ark! By Brian Simpson

Scientists, in their absolute wisdom, seeing the writing on the wall for mankind, we suppose, have moved beyond the classic ark seed vault on planet earth, and now are proposing to put one on the moon. Here is the take on this, then I deliver the obvious refutation:

The Svalbard Global Seed Vault on the Norwegian island of Spitsbergen in the remote Arctic Svalbard archipelago appears to be losing its appeal as scientists propose a "lunar ark" to house millions of species of seeds, sperm, eggs, and DNA. 

A team of researchers from the University of Arizona, led by Jekan Thanga, proposed building a massive "ark" on the moon as a "modern global insurance policy" against natural disasters, socio-economic chaos, asteroids, and the threat of nuclear war. 

Earth is naturally a volatile environment," Thanga said in the study titled "Lunar Pits and Lava Tubes for a Modern Ark." The team debuted the study at the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) Aerospace Conference last Saturday. 

"An ark, just like Noah's in the Bible, could store endangered species more cost-effectively than protecting them on earth or creating an artificial ecosystem," Thanga said.

The researcher proposed building the ark in a lunar pit and or lava tubes, holding upwards of 6.7 million species of seeds, sperm, eggs, and DNA.

Thanga said due to instability, Earth-based repositories, such as Svalbard, could leave specimens vulnerable. 


Thanga's presentation explained that various species would be cryogenically preserved. "We can still save them until the tech advances to then reintroduce these species — in other words, save them for another day," he added. 

To transport upwards of 6.7 million samples, it would take 250 rocket launches. By comparison, the International Space Station took only 40 rocket launches to build.

 The scientist suggested solar panels would power the facility. However, future moon bases will likely be powered with miniature nuclear reactors, as we've explained before. 

Here's the full presentation: 

"We propose development of a modern day ark to be housed inside lunar lava tubes. The ark would house eggs, sperms, seeds and other DNA matter from all of the endangered species on Earth. It would serve as a global insurance policy. Earth faces probability of peril from various natural disasters and human threats such as global nuclear war that could wipe out a large number of species in a short time. Lunar lava tubes were discovered in 2013 and are likely to have remained pristine for 3-4 billion years. They are only 4-5 days from Earth. They are an excellent shelter against lunar surface temperature swings, cosmic radiation and micro-meteorites. The ark would house these endangered species in cryo-conditions of -180 C and colder. Our research shows that new technologies are need to make this initiative possible. It will require substantial investments and advances in robotics to operate under cryo-conditions," he said.”

The obvious problem here is that these scientists are preparing for a global catastrophe, such as nuclear war, thus dictating seed security by going off planet. But, given that risk, for argument sake, it is most likely that the facilities to get to the moon will be destroyed in the catastrophe, hence rendering the whole program useless. Or, the earth will be so devastated that the whole exercise becomes pointless. The only hope would be to keep the seeds there on the moon for off earth survival in space stations, but in that case one might as well get the space station up, then worry about stocking it with seeds.

But, there is another really big problem with the moon. Lacking an atmosphere, the moon is subject to relentless meteor strikes, evidenced by its cratered surface. Who is to say that the seed vault will not be taken out by a large, hot rock, ending all of those sperm?

This is yet another example of scientific irrationality, starting with a basic idea, adding technologies, getting excited, losing track of common sense, and producing ultimately absurdity!




No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Tuesday, 28 June 2022