Police Tasered 95 Year-Old Dementia Lady on Walking Frame, in Nursing Home: Was this a Threat to National Security? By Mrs Vera West
New South Wales now has its own version of the George Floyd-style police brutality case. Only the person is white and aged, so there will be no street protests here. The story involves a 95-year-old lady suffering from dementia, in a nursing home, on a walking frame. She got agitated and grabbed, I would imagine slowly, a steak knife. Nursing staff rang the police, because it must have been too difficult to quietly talk to her, or offer her an ice-cream (she drops the knife to take it), or just take the knife out of her hand. But police had the answer, and tasered her. And now this poor lady is receiving end-of-life care in Cooma district hospital, after being critically injured when she hit the floor after being tasered. It is a deeply disturbing story.
If this lady dies, will there be charges laid against the officer, or is this the last we hear of this? The story made me both sad, and angry. I dread going into a nursing home, and hope the good Lord sees fit to take me before that time. At my age, it may not be long, but I have lived a full life.
“New South Wales’s top cop says she will not watch confronting video of a 95-year-old grandmother being Tasered in a nursing home, as the elderly woman’s condition deteriorates in hospital.
Clare Nowland, 95, was using a walking frame when she was hit with a Taser at an aged care facility in Cooma in the early hours of Wednesday, after she allegedly failed to drop a steak knife.
The mother of eight is now receiving end-of-life care in Cooma district hospital, surrounded by her distraught family after being critically injured when she was Tasered and fell to the floor.
The incident was captured on body-worn camera by the two officers attending, but the NSW police commissioner, Karen Webb, told reporters she had not watched the video.
“I don’t really intend to, no,” Webb said in Sydney on Saturday.
“I’ve heard what’s in the body worn, and I don’t see it necessary that I actually view it.”
Police would not make the footage public, she said, adding it was protected under the Surveillance Act.
“We don’t intend to release it unless there’s a process at the end of this that would allow it to be released.”
Staff from the Yallambee Lodge nursing home called police after Nowland, who has dementia and is 43kg, took a serrated steak knife from the kitchen into a small treatment room.
Police and ambulance officers tried to get Nowland to drop the knife before a senior constable fired his Taser once as she slowly approached them. She fell and struck her head on the floor.
The critical incident investigation has been elevated to “level one” due to Nowland suffering an injury that could lead to her death.
Police had been with Nowland’s family since the incident, and they deserved a thorough investigation to take place without speculation, Webb said.
“What we know so far is what happened, what we don’t yet know is why it happened,” she said.
“Mrs Nowland and her family deserve that this is done properly. This will take time.
“We need to ensure that the officers involved in this matter are afforded procedural fairness, and that anything that we say [does not] prejudice the investigation.”
She said the investigation would be highly complex and sensitive, requiring detectives to interview all staff and residents from the aged care home.
“That’s a delicate and time consuming role that they have, but necessary,” she said.
Webb said she had spent time at the Cooma district hospital with the family on Friday, and the next few days would likely be difficult for the family.
“My condolences and thoughts are with the family at the moment,” she said.
Family friend and community advocate Andrew Thaler said Nowland’s condition had worsened as her family remained by her bedside.
“Her breathing has been getting shallower, but she’s still with us,” he said on Saturday.
The officer who fired the Taser has been taken off active duty.
The assistant commissioner, Peter Cotter, who is leading the investigation, declined to say whether that officer might face criminal charges, saying it would breach procedural fairness.
The assistant commissioner said he had seen the body camera footage and agreed with a family friend it was confronting.
He also declined to release it publicly.
On Saturday, the aged care minister, Anika Wells, said the Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission was conducting a separate investigation and had sought further information from the aged care provider about the incident.”
Comments