The Great Toilet Paper Mystery Brian Simpson
The interesting basically Left site, The Conversation, has an article on the toilet paper buy up phenomenon, gripping the world. The nutshell is that toilet paper has disappeared from the supermarket shelves, but not tissues, or paper towels, all good to wipe your butt in a pinch, so to speak. Why? Here are their experts on this:
“Niki Edwards, School of Public Health and Social Work, Queensland University of Technology: Toilet paper symbolises control. We use it to “tidy up” and “clean up”. It deals with a bodily function that is somewhat taboo.
When people hear about the coronavirus, they are afraid of losing control. And toilet paper feels like a way to maintain control over hygiene and cleanliness. People don’t seem interested in substitutes. Supermarket shelves are still full of other paper towels and tissues. The media has a lot to answer for in regards to messages around this virus and messages to the public. While honesty about threats is critical, building hysteria and promoting inappropriate behaviours is far from ideal.
Brian Cook, Community Engagement for Disaster Risk Reduction project, University of Melbourne:
It’s an interesting question. My suspicion is that it is to do with how people react to stress: they want an element of comfort and security. For many Westerners there is a “yuck factor” associated with non-toilet paper cleaning. I expect there is also a pragmatic element. Toilet paper is a product that takes a lot of space, and is therefore not something people have a lot of under normal circumstances. A lot of people likely also use toilet paper as a tissue, and therefore imagine themselves needing a lot if they have the flu or a flu-like illness. Stocking up on toilet paper is also a relatively cheap action, and people like to think that they are “doing something” when they feel at risk. David Savage, Newcastle Business School, University of Newcastle: I think it is the perfect product. It is completely non-perishable and one of the few products that you can stock up on that you are guaranteed to use eventually. I don’t know for certain but I suspect that most people only buy toilet paper when they just about run out, which could be a problem if you need to stay isolated for two weeks. So I think this is just a preparation process, because we have seen that toilet paper has become a shortage item elsewhere.
Alex Russell, School of Health, Medical and Applied Sciences, Central Queensland University:
There are a few factors at play here. People aren’t only stockpiling toilet paper. All sorts of items are sold out, like face masks and hand sanitiser. Things like canned goods and other non-perishable foods are also selling well. People are scared, and they’re bunkering down. They’re buying what they need and one of the items is toilet paper. I think we’re noticing the toilet paper more than the other things because toilet paper packs are big items that take up a lot of shelf space. Seeing a small product sold out at the supermarket (such as hand sanitiser) is not that unusual, and it’s only a small hole in the shelf that is often temporarily filled with nearby products. But if the toilet paper is gone, that’s a massive amount of shelf space that can’t readily be replaced with other things nearby. A second reason we might be noticing it more is because there aren’t easy substitutions. If the supermarket is out of a particular ingredient for dinner, you can just get something else, or an entirely different dinner. But if there’s not a roll of toilet paper, then that’s pretty frustrating for everyone. Sure, tissues or paper towels, but it’s not quite the same, is it?
I put this to the League of Rights resident, when we can find him, survival expert, John Steele:
Yeah Brian, these guys come close to nailing it. The perfect score answer would involve all of the points raised. Most importantly, toilet paper is simply the latest of a series of products to disappear from the supermarket shelves, with hand sanitiser and masks being the first to go. It is hard to even get industrial P2 dust masks now, even though they are useless for viral protection.
The short of the long of this, is that people are not being stampeded as one authority above implies, but are acting rationally under adverse and uncertain conditions. Those upset that they do not have toilet paper should have stockpiled it before this coronavirus problem even began, because breakdown and chaos is the natural state of the world, not order and warm and fuzzy feelings.
Readers should note the headline of the above article: “Don't panic, just shop! MailOnline readers share the coronavirus 'essentials' they're stockpiling from Pot Noodles and Calpol to water and beauty cream - as shops RATION hand sanitisers and prices skyrocket on eBay.”
Wow, that sums it all up!