A Granny’s Guide to Omega-3 and Omega-6 Balance for a Healthy Heart, By Mrs. Vera West
As I sit here with my cuppa, I've been pondering how to keep our tickers humming along nicely in our golden years. You've likely heard the chatter about omega-3 and omega-6 fats, they're vital for keeping us spry, but too much of either can cause a bit of a trouble. Dr. Mercola's been going on about how too many omega-3s, especially from those fish oil capsules, might lead to a wonky heart rhythm called atrial fibrillation (AFib). And don't get me started on omega-6s, they're everywhere in our modern tucker and can stir up trouble if we overdo it. So, let's have a chat about how to get these fats just right for a long, healthy life.
Omega-3s, like EPA and DHA, are absolute treasures. They calm inflammation, keep your heart and brain in fine fettle, and even help with those creaky joints. You'll find them in lovely fish, like salmon, sardines, and anchovies, or in krill oil, which your body soaks up like a sponge. But here's the catch: piling on too many omega-3s, especially from supplements (over 1g a day), can muck up your heart's rhythm. It's something to do with making the membranes in your heart cells too slippery, which can lead to AFib, a condition that makes your heart flutter like a startled chook, and nobody wants that.
Omega-6s aren't the bad guys, they help build cell walls and keep things ticking over. But our diets are chock-a-block with them, thanks to processed foods, cheap oils like soybean and sunflower, and even some nuts. Too much omega-6 can whip up inflammation, which isn't kind to your heart, joints, or general wellbeing. The trick is to get your omega-6 to omega-3 ratio down to about 4:1 or better, instead of the 10:1 or worse we often see these days.
The best way to get your omega-3s is from proper food, not pills. Treat yourself to 2–3 serves (about 100g each) of fatty fish a week, think wild-caught Aussie salmon, sardines, or those little anchovies. They'll give you around 500–1000mg of EPA/DHA a day, which is spot-on for keeping your heart happy without any funny business. Fish also come with extra nutrients to keep you glowing. If fish isn't your cup of tea, try flaxseeds, chia seeds, or walnuts for a plant-based omega-3 boost, though they're not quite as potent.
For omega-6s, go easy on the processed stuff. Skip the supermarket pies, biscuits, and anything fried in those cheap oils. Cook with olive oil or avocado oil, and don't go overboard with nuts, a small handful's plenty for a snack.
Only pop omega-3 supplements if you're not getting enough from your meals, like if you're vegetarian or just can't face fish. Here's myadvice:
Krill oil's the bee's knees because it's easier for your body to use. If you pick fish oil, go for a top-notch brand that's been checked for purity and hasn't gone off.
Stick to 250–500mg of EPA/DHA a day to steer clear of heart hiccups. High doses are only for special cases, and you'll want your doctor's nod first.
Give your capsules a whiff. If they smell like the fishmonger's bin, toss 'em out. Rancid oils do more harm than good.
To keep things balanced, cut down on omega-6-heavy foods:
Say no to takeaway chips, packaged snacks, and anything swimming in veggie oils.
Watch out for soybean, sunflower, or corn oil in salad dressings or sauces. Olive oil's your friend.
Rustle up your meals at home with olive oil, avocado oil, or a dab of grass-fed butter. It's kinder to your heart and tastes a treat.
If your heart's been a bit iffy or you've got diabetes, be extra careful with supplements, as AFib's more likely. Pop in to see your GP and maybe get a heart check-up to be safe.
Your age, genes, and lifestyle, like a daily walk or a good night's kip, affect how these fats work for you. If you've had heart troubles, you might need to go lighter on the supplements.
Keeping your omega-3s and omega-6s in check is like knitting a cosy scarf, it takes a bit of care, but the result's worth it. Load up on delicious fish for your omega-3s, cut back on processed foods and cheap oils to tame omega-6s, and only use supplements if you really need them, keeping doses low and quality high. Keep an eye on your health, especially if your heart's had a rough patch, and have a chat with your doctor before changing things up.
With a bit of home cooking, some smart shopping, and a lifestyle full of gentle walks and good rest, you'll be set for a heart as strong as an ox and a life full of zest, like me. Well, almost.
https://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2025/05/11/omega-3-paradox.aspx
Story at-a-glance
Omega-3 fats like EPA and DHA offer heart benefits, but excessive intake, especially from supplements, increases the risk of atrial fibrillation (AFib), a heart rhythm disorder
High doses of omega-3s, particularly from supplements, can disrupt heart cell function and electrical signaling, triggering AFib. However, low doses from food sources are generally safe
Natural omega-3s in phospholipid form (found in krill oil and wild-caught fatty fish) are more easily absorbed than the synthetic triglycerides in many fish oil supplements. Rancid omega-3 supplements could be harmful due to oxidation
Studies suggest that daily omega-3 intake exceeding 1 gram, particularly from supplements, may increase AFib risk, especially in those with pre-existing heart conditions. Lower doses and whole food sources appear safer
Prioritize omega-3s from fatty fish like wild-caught Alaskan salmon, sardines, anchovies, mackerel and herring. If supplementing, choose krill oil or high-quality, low-dose fish oil, and consult a healthcare professional, especially if you have health concerns or take medications
Omega-3 fatty acids are a type of fat widely recognized for their health benefits, particularly for the heart.1 Numerous studies suggest they help reduce inflammation, boost brain function and offer protection against cardiovascular problems. However, as with many nutritional elements, the specifics matter. It's not simply about consuming omega-3s, but also the quantity, the type and the quality of what you consume.
You may have heard that excessive omega-3 intake, especially from certain supplements, could negatively impact heart health and contribute to a condition called atrial fibrillation (AFib). This article explores the complexities of omega-3s, examining their effects, both positive and negative, on the heart.
It also addresses two frequently overlooked issues — the prevalence of less natural forms of omega-3s in the market and the risk of rancidity, which can transform a beneficial substance into a harmful one. Recent research examining the connection between two key omega-3s, EPA and DHA, and AFib, as well as their broader impact on health, will also be discussed.
The relationship between omega-3s and heart health can be visualized as a balancing act. Too little can be detrimental, but too much can also pose risks, albeit through different mechanisms. This can be conceptualized as a U-shaped curve — deficiency on one end, excess on the other, with optimal intake at the curve's base.
Omega-3s and the Risk of AFib
In the featured video above, Nicolas Verhoeven, Ph.D., talks about the disadvantages of high omega-3 consumption, particularly from supplements. One specific side effect is AFib,2 a type of arrhythmia that causes an irregular and often rapid heartbeat.3 AFib can lead to complications such as blood clots, strokes, heart failure and other serious cardiovascular problems.4
•Evidence suggests a connection between excessive omega-3s and AFib — Scientists are still working to understand exactly how excessive omega-3s might lead to AFib, but research suggests there's an association. AFib is a relatively common heart rhythm disorder, particularly among older adults, becoming significantly more prevalent in those over 80.5
•Omega-3s impact heart cells by integrating into cell membranes — To understand how omega-3s might influence AFib, it's important to consider their effects at the cellular level, especially within heart muscle cells.
Each cell in the body is enclosed by a protective barrier called the cell membrane.6 This membrane is not a rigid structure; it's more like a fluid composed of various fats, including omega-3s and omega-6s. When you consume omega-3s, they become incorporated into these membranes, altering their fluidity.7
•Changes in membrane fluidity affect electrical heart signals — In heart muscle cells, these changes in membrane fluidity can affect the electrical signals that regulate the heartbeat. Heart cells communicate through electrical signals that coordinate their contractions and relaxations.8 These signals rely on the movement of charged particles called ions (such as sodium, potassium and calcium) across the cell membrane through specialized channels.
•Excessively fluid membranes may disrupt Piezo ion channels — One theory suggests that an overabundance of omega-3s can make the cell membrane excessively fluid, disrupting the function of these ion channels, particularly a channel known as the Piezo channel.9
This channel requires a specific shape to function correctly. If the membrane becomes too fluid due to high omega-3 content, the channel might open prematurely, allowing ions to enter the cell at inappropriate times.
This disruption can interfere with the normal electrical signaling of the cell, thereby triggering an irregular heartbeat.10
However, the Piezo channel is just one piece of the puzzle. Omega-3s can also influence the activity of other ion channels, affecting their opening and closing mechanisms. They can even impact the production of these channels by the cell. Studies have demonstrated that omega-3 exposure can significantly alter the quantity of channel proteins a cell produces.11
The Positive Effects of Omega-3s Against Inflammation
Despite the potential risks associated with excessive intake, omega-3s like EPA and DHA offer significant health benefits, such as reducing inflammation,12 supporting the immune system, helping prevent excessive blood clotting and protecting blood vessels.13
•When incorporated into cell membranes, omega-3s improve the efficiency of cell signaling14 — They also compete with proinflammatory omega-6s. By reducing the availability of omega-6s, omega-3s help control inflammation, a key factor in many chronic diseases, including heart disease. Your body uses EPA and DHA to create specialized substances that further reduce inflammation and aid in healing.
•Both too little and too much omega-3s can be harmful — The complex relationship between omega-3s and heart health underscores the importance of consuming the right amount. As previously mentioned, this relationship can be visualized as a U-shaped curve, where both deficiency and excess can be detrimental. Determining the ideal intake is challenging, as it likely varies based on individual factors such as genetics, dietary habits and overall health.
•High supplement doses may raise AFib risk — However, most research indicates that consuming several grams of omega-3s daily, particularly from supplements, may increase the risk of adverse effects. Studies have suggested that exceeding 1 gram of omega-3s daily elevates the risk of AFib.15
The Type of Omega-3 Matters — Natural vs. Processed
Besides the quantity, the form of omega-3s is also a crucial consideration. In nature, omega-3s primarily exist as phospholipids.16 This is especially true in seafood like fatty fish and krill.17 Phospholipids are essential components of cell membranes, making them readily usable by the body.18
•Supplements usually contain less bioavailable triglycerides — However, most omega-3 supplements contain synthetic triglycerides, often due to the extraction and processing methods used for fish oil.
While triglycerides can still provide benefits, they are not as easily absorbed as phospholipids.19 Research suggests that phospholipids have higher bioavailability, meaning smaller doses may achieve similar effects compared to larger doses of triglycerides.20
Furthermore, the body requires additional processing to convert triglycerides into a usable form, which can place a burden on the liver and may be less efficient for some individuals.
•Another significant concern with omega-3 supplements, particularly fish oil, is rancidity21 — Omega-3s, especially EPA and DHA, are susceptible to oxidation, a process that degrades the fats and produces harmful free radicals22 that damage cells and promote inflammation, counteracting the intended benefits of omega-3s.
•Rancid fish oil often has a strong, unpleasant odor and taste23 — This indicates oxidation and signifies that the oil should not be consumed. Unfortunately, many consumers are unaware of this issue, and some manufacturers attempt to mask the odor with artificial flavorings. Consuming rancid omega-3s is more harmful than not taking them at all.
What the Research Tells Us
Recent reviews of studies have provided valuable insights into the relationship between omega-3s and AFib. One review indicated that daily consumption of more than 1 gram of omega-3s increases the risk of AFib by approximately 50%, particularly in individuals with pre-existing heart conditions, high triglyceride levels or diabetes.24
•Findings from major trials support increased risk with high doses — This aligns with the findings of studies like REDUCE-IT25 and STRENGTH,26 which used higher doses of omega-3s and observed increased AFib risk. These findings suggest that individuals with these risk factors should exercise caution with omega-3 supplementation.
•REDUCE-IT trial showed cardiovascular benefits but increased AFib risk — Several large-scale studies have investigated the effects of omega-3 supplements. The REDUCE-IT trial27 administered a high dose of purified EPA (4 grams daily) to individuals with heart problems. While this regimen reduced certain cardiovascular events, it also increased the risk of AFib.
•STRENGTH trial found no heart benefits and increased AFib risk — Similarly, the STRENGTH trial28 used a comparable high dose of both EPA and DHA, did not demonstrate any reduction in heart problems, and also observed an elevated AFib risk. These studies suggest that high-dose omega-3 supplements may not be the optimal approach for heart protection and could be harmful.
•Low-dose omega-3 studies show little to no increased AFib risk — On the other hand, studies using lower omega-3 doses (less than 1 gram per day) have generally not found a significant increase in AFib risk.
The ASCEND study,29 which focused on individuals with diabetes, and the VITAL study,30 which included a large population without pre-existing AFib, both used lower doses and did not observe a substantial increase in AFib incidence. This supports the idea that lower doses are safer.
•The OMEMI study shows risk with higher doses in older adults — The OMEMI study,31 which examined older adults who had recently experienced a heart attack, administered a higher omega-3 dose (1.8 grams per day) and found a trend toward increased AFib risk. This study highlights the importance of considering individual factors such as age and recent cardiac events when considering omega-3 supplementation.
These studies, combined with other research, highlight several key points — Dosage is a critical factor, with higher doses of omega-3 supplements appearing to be associated with a greater risk of AFib; individuals with pre-existing heart conditions or risk factors may be more susceptible to this risk; and lower doses of omega-3s generally do not appear to significantly increase AFib risk. To make informed decisions about omega-3 consumption, consider the following:
Prioritize whole food sources such as wild-caught fatty fish like Alaskan salmon, sardines, anchovies, mackerel and herring, which provide omega-3s in their natural form along with other essential nutrients.
If considering supplements, krill oil, which contains omega-3s in phospholipid form, is a better option, but choose reputable brands and pay attention to dosage.
Exercise caution with high-dose fish oil supplements, particularly those in triglyceride form, and if using fish oil, opt for lower doses and look for products tested for purity and freshness.
Always check fish oil for signs of rancidity, such as a strong fishy odor or taste, and store supplements properly.
Consult with a healthcare professional before starting any omega-3 supplementation, especially if you have existing health conditions or are taking medications.
Expanding on the Benefits of Omega-3s
Omega-3s are essential fatty acids, meaning the body cannot produce them and must obtain them through diet. They play a vital role in cell membrane structure and function, influencing how cells communicate and operate. Omega-3s maintain membrane flexibility, which is essential for various processes, including nerve function and immune responses.
•Omega-3s, especially DHA, are also crucial for brain health — DHA is a major structural component of the brain, essential for development in infants and children and for maintaining cognitive function throughout life. Research suggests potential benefits for memory, focus, mood regulation, and even reducing symptoms of depression and anxiety.32
•Omega-3s also possess potent anti-inflammatory properties33 — They help regulate the body's inflammatory response, which, when chronic, contributes to various health problems like heart disease, arthritis and some cancers. By reducing inflammation, omega-3s contribute to overall health and well-being.
•Omega-3s offer heart benefits, but high supplement doses may pose AFib risk — Returning to the heart, it's important to reiterate the complexity of the relationship between omega-3s and cardiovascular health. While generally considered beneficial, the potential link to AFib warrants careful consideration.
The research suggests that dosage is a key factor, with higher doses from supplements being more strongly associated with increased AFib risk. The specific types of omega-3s, EPA and DHA, may also have varying effects.
•Quality is paramount when considering omega-3 supplements — The susceptibility of omega-3s to oxidation, leading to harmful byproducts, emphasizes the importance of choosing high-quality products from reputable manufacturers. Look for products that have undergone testing for purity and freshness, check expiration dates and store supplements properly.
•Supplements may be considered if dietary intake is insufficient or if specific health conditions warrant their use — Consult with a healthcare professional before starting any omega-3 supplementation, especially if you have existing health issues or are taking medications.
If supplementing, prioritize krill oil or phospholipid-form fish oil for better absorption, choose reputable brands that prioritize quality and purity, and start with lower doses, increasing them only under medical guidance.
Sufficient omega-3 intake is part of a larger picture of health, along with a balanced diet, regular physical activity, high-quality sleep and stress management. By making informed choices about lifestyle and understanding the nuances of omega-3 intake, you'll be able to optimize your health and minimize potential risks.
Comments