There is a particular kind of official silence that says more than any document ever could. It is the silence of a government that has the numbers, has been ordered to hand them over by its own information commissioner, and is spending public money to keep them in a drawer. If the figures were flattering, they would be on a press release with a photo op and a minister's name at the top. Nobody appeals a ruling to suppress good news.

The Centre for Migration Control asked the Ministry of Justice, under freedom of information law, for the crime figures of foreign nationals. Rejected. The reason given was that disclosure could lead to "identification of the individuals concerned," and that "the interests of the data subjects to safeguard personal information outweigh the legitimate interest in this case." That is the entire argument, and it collapses on contact with the word table. Aggregate counts broken down by nationality and offence type are not a name, an address, or a date of birth. Denmark publishes exactly this material. It manages to do so without unmasking anyone, because counting is not naming. If a spreadsheet cell reading "Algerian nationals, rape convictions, n" identified a human being, then every published crime statistic in the Western world would be a privacy violation, and the Home Office would have to shut down its own data portal tomorrow.

And note what is already published. Foreigners accounted for 14.1 per cent of sex offences in 2025 in the figures the public can see. So the government's position is not that this information is dangerous in principle, it has conceded the topline. Its position is that the breakdown is dangerous. Which raises the obvious question: dangerous to whom? Not to a victim. Not to a defendant, who has already been through a court. Dangerous only to a political class that would prefer the public not know which national cohorts are driving which categories of crime. The topline number is a fig leaf; the granularity is the thing they cannot bear to release, and the reason they cannot bear it is that granularity is where the argument lives.

Because the fragments that have leaked out are not ambiguous. Analysis of the 2021 census against prison rolls found foreigners 27 per cent more likely to be imprisoned than British citizens, and then the distribution fell apart into something far starker. Albanians at an imprisonment rate of 232.33 per 10,000, Kosovars at 150, Vietnamese at 148.88, Algerians at 124.41, Jamaicans at 110.77, Eritreans at 110.7, Iraqis at 104.43, Somalis at 100.37. British citizens at 14. Germans at 4.68. Italians at 4.96. Indians at 6.24. Chinese at 9.39. That is not a story about foreigners. Germans and Indians and Chinese are foreigners too, and they are safer than the native population by a wide margin. It is a story about which foreigners, and that is precisely the sort of story that requires nationality-level data to tell honestly, and precisely the sort of story that cannot be told if the data stays locked in a ministry basement.

This is the point the defenders of the refusal never grapple with. Suppressing the breakdown does not protect immigrants; it smears them. When the public is told only that foreigners commit 14.1 per cent of sex offences and is then denied the composition of that 14.1 per cent, the natural human inference is to suspect everyone in the category. The people who would benefit most from publication are the Germans, the Indians, the Chinese, the Sri Lankans, the groups whose numbers would clear them. The government is not shielding the innocent; it is protecting a blank space that everyone fills in with their worst guess. That is not data protection. That is the manufacture of suspicion by omission, and it is being done in the name of the very people it harms.

Then there is the detail that ought to end the argument: the government is not merely refusing new requests, it is fighting to reverse a ruling from the Information Commissioner ordering the release of full foreign crime statistics for England and Wales from 2018 to 2024. An independent regulator looked at the same privacy objection, weighed it, and found it wanting. The state's response was to lawyer up. Ask yourself what a bureaucracy does when it is confident the numbers exonerate it. It publishes them, loudly, and dares its critics to keep talking. What it does not do is spend years and legal fees litigating to keep seven years of its own statistics out of public view.

Robert Bates of the Centre for Migration Control put it more bluntly than the institutions would like: "The extraordinary lengths being taken to conceal the truth suggest the Government knows there is a major problem but is more concerned about the public finding out than taking meaningful steps to tackle migrant crime." That is the correct read. The ministry's own press line, nearly 12,000 foreign national offenders removed since July 2024, up 41 per cent, laws changed so foreign prisoners can be deported earlier, is an implicit admission that the volume is large enough to require a deportation programme of that scale. They will tell you the enforcement numbers. They will not tell you the crime numbers that justify them. You are permitted to know the medicine and forbidden to see the diagnosis.

And this is the deeper rot. The FOI system exists precisely so that the public can audit the state's own claims about itself. When the state can refuse on elasticity like "data subjects' interests," and then appeal an adverse ruling, the mechanism is decorative. Transparency becomes a courtesy the government extends when it suits them and withdraws when it doesn't, which means it was never transparency at all, only public relations with a legal department attached. The revolving door between the agencies that generate these figures and the institutions that would be embarrassed by them is not a bug in the arrangement; it is the arrangement.

So: if there is nothing to hide, why cover? There is no innocent answer to that question, because innocence has an obvious and cheap response available: publish the table, redact nothing that identifies no one, and let the numbers speak. Every month the Ministry of Justice declines to do that, it is not protecting a single foreign national from embarrassment. It is protecting itself from a conversation it has decided the British public is not allowed to have about who is being let in, what they are doing, and who is paying for the decision. The refusal is the finding. The cover is the confession.

https://www.breitbart.com/europe/2026/11/15/british-government-refuses-to-release-full-migrant-crime-statistics/