Parts of the American Left are growing tired of identity politics. After years of framing politics around race, gender, and minority recognition, some activists and candidates are rediscovering the older language of class, economic redistribution, and collective control of resources. Figures such as Bernie Sanders and New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani have helped shift the emphasis toward housing costs, wages, and public ownership. The Democratic Socialists of America have backed dozens of primary winners. Polls show majorities of Democratic voters viewing socialism favourably. Le Monde describes the change as a turn away from cultural grievance toward Marxist-inspired economic analysis.

The move is understandable as a tactical response to electoral setbacks. Identity politics alienated parts of the working-class electorate that Democrats once took for granted. Economic messaging about rents, health care, and inequality polls better with those voters. Yet the substance being rediscovered is not a novel diagnosis of market failures. It is a version of the same socialist program that has been tried, repeatedly, and has failed with consistent and often catastrophic results.

The historical record is not ambiguous. The Soviet Union, Maoist China, Cuba, Cambodia under the Khmer Rouge, and the Eastern Bloc, produced shortages, repression, mass emigration, and tens of millions of deaths. Venezuela offers the clearest recent example in the Western Hemisphere. Once among the richer countries in Latin America, it nationalised industries, imposed price controls, and subordinated production to political priorities under Chávez and Maduro. The result was hyperinflation, the collapse of oil output, widespread hunger, the flight of roughly a quarter of the population, and the destruction of a middle class. Similar patterns appeared in Cuba after 1959 and in Nicaragua under Ortega. In each case the initial promises of equality and abundance gave way to shortages of basic goods, political monopolies, and declining living standards.

Proponents now distinguish "democratic socialism" from these precedents. The distinction is thinner than claimed. The core mechanisms; state direction of investment, suppression of price signals, expansion of public ownership, and the political use of redistribution to lock in support, produce the same incentive problems wherever they are applied at scale. Nordic countries that socialists sometimes cite are high-tax market economies with private ownership of the means of production, not socialist systems. Where socialist parties have governed in Europe, they have typically moderated toward mixed economies once the costs of full nationalisation became clear.

The American rediscovery is therefore not an advance. Identity politics and socialism share a common feature: both treat group outcomes as the proper object of state power and both struggle to acknowledge trade-offs. The first divides the population by ascriptive categories; the second divides it by class and seeks to override market allocation. Neither has a good record of delivering the material improvements it promises once it moves from rhetoric to administration. The failures of the twentieth century were not accidents of particular leaders or particular countries. They followed from the attempt to replace decentralised decisions about production and consumption with centralised political ones. That experiment has already been run. The results were disastrous.

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/opinion/article/2026/11/03/disillusioned-by-identity-politics-the-american-left-rediscovers-socialism_6769765_23.html